
We should insist that the immigrant who comes here in good faith becomes an American and assimilates himself to us, he shall be treated on an exact equality with everyone else, for it is an outrage to discriminate against any such man because of creed, or birthplace, or origin. But this is predicated upon the man’s becoming in very fact an American, and nothing but an American…There can be no divided allegiance here. Any man who says he is an American, but something else also, isn’t an American at all. We have room for but one flag, the American flag, which symbolizes all wars against liberty and civilization, We have room for but one language here, and that is the English language…and we have room for but one sole loyalty and that is a loyalty to the American people.
Theodore Roosevelt 1907
One of the questions asked of Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton during the Democratic Presidential debate last week was whether or not the United States should be a bi-lingual speaking country (meaning Spanish).
The following responses are verbatim from the transcript of the debate.
Question: Right now, there are more than 30 million people in this country who speak Spanish.
(APPLAUSE)
Many of them are right here. By the year 2050, there will be 120 million Hispanics in the United States. Now, is there any downside, Senator Clinton, to the United States becoming (SPEAKING SPANISH) becoming a bilingual nation? Is there a limit?
Clinton’s response: Well, I think it’s important for as many Americans as possible to do what I have never been able to do, and that is learn another language and try to be bilingual because that connects us to the rest of the world.
I think it is important, though, that English remain our common unifying language because that brings our country together in a way that we have seen generations of immigrants coming to our shores be able to be part of the American experience and pursue the American dream.
You know, I have been adamantly against the efforts by some to make English the official language. That I do not believe is appropriate, and I have voted against it and spoken against it.
I represent New York. We have 170 languages in New York City alone. And I do not think that we should be, in any way, discriminating against people who do not speak English, who use facilities like hospitals or have to go to court to enforce their rights.
But I do think that English does remain an important part of the American experience. So I encourage people to become bilingual. But I also want to see English remain the common, unifying language of our country.
Someone please translate the double speak for me so we all understand how English is our common unifying language, but not the official language.
In closing Hillary stumbles to the finish with this gem. “English does remain an important part of the American experience”.
The American experience? Since when did American citizenship become a day at Disneyland? Being an American citizen is a privilege. At a minimum citizens should be required to read, write and speak the language embraced by our founding fathers. It is the responsibility of legal immigrants to assimilate with America. I don’t recall seeing the Constitution or Bill of Rights written in any language other then English. Those who want to enjoy the protection offered by these documents should not be allowed to take what we have to offer in the way of jobs, health care and lifestyle and leave us to clean the cotton candy and churro wrappers left at the exit turnstiles of ‘It’s A Small World’.
Hillary says “I do not think that we should be, in any way, discriminating against people who do not speak English, who use facilities like hospitals or have to go to court to enforce their rights.”
It is not discriminatory to expect citizens to read, write and understand English. Remember Theodore Roosevelt’s proclamation? Learn the language of your adopted country. Assimilate with your fellow citizens. The promises of freedom and liberty in America require personal accountability by its citizens. Take responsibility for learning English if you want to live here.
Otherwise adios, Salaam, Tsedesutyun, Ciao, Adéu, Dag, Wiedersehen, Shalom, Bless, Daa daa, Mar sin leat, Sayonara, Ha det bra, Sudie, Bulya yo, Ate mais tarde, Hasta luego, Adjö, Sun-kia, Veda, Tam biêt, Zayt gesunt, Usale kahle, or in good ole American English… See ya.
OBAMA: Well, I think it is important that everyone learns English and that we have that process of binding ourselves together as a country. I think that’s very important.
I also think that every student should be learning a second language, because…
(APPLAUSE)
… you know, so, when you start getting into a debate about bilingual education, for example, now, I want to make sure that children who are coming out of Spanish-speaking households had the opportunity to learn and are not falling behind.
If bilingual education helps them do that, I want to give them the opportunity.
But I also want to make sure that English-speaking children are getting foreign languages because this world is becoming more interdependent and part of the process of America’s continued leadership in the world is going to be our capacity to communicate across boundaries, across borders, and that’s something frankly where we’ve fallen behind.
One of the failures of No Child Left Behind, a law that I think a lot of local and state officials have been troubled by, is that it is so narrowly focused on standardized tests that it has pushed out a lot of important learning that needs to take place.
(APPLAUSE)
And foreign languages is one of those areas that I think has been neglected. I want to put more resources into it.
Obama’s response was no more clear or direct. ”I think it is important that everyone learns English and that we have that process of binding ourselves together as a country. I think that’s very important.”
These are two Presidential candidates who have made a political career out of manipulating the English language to frame the issues as a matter of convenience. Neither of them are committed to setting minimal language expectations for legal immigrants assimilating in America, let alone establish English as the official language.
Any new immigration reform discussion should include an English proficiency requirement. 30 States have enacted legislation declaring English as the official language. It is time for Congress to step up and have the stugots to do the same.
Any questions?